Can AI keep our cast consistent?

One model. Different scenes and prompts.

Test details

25 raw attempts · 1 model

Fixed: Updated body and face references for each character.
Changed: Character, scene and prompt revision across 26 attempts.
Check: Compare each output to its own character sheets; inspect face and body drift.

Google Nano Banana Pro only. Changing scenes and prompt history do not measure model differences.

Recorded October 10, 2026. References are shown per attempt.

Iris rooftop tests →

Sort

How it sorts

Within each test: highest complete AI rating, then lower historical cost. Partial panels stay unranked by rating. Lowest cost reverses that priority. Unknown values follow known ones. Ranges use their upper estimate. Human votes stay separate.

Video uses USD per delivered minute. Images use USD per generation until complete spend and human usability checks establish cost per usable image. Failed submissions and retries stay in the test history. Fees and taxes are unconfirmed.

Attempt 1 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

AI 80/100Est. $0.1412/image

References

Reference details

Gravis · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Body direction accepted; left-profile panel remains three-quarter.

Gravis · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Current face reference; complete pack validation pending.

Attempt 1: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

gravis-action-concise. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.141242; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judges80/1005/5

4 Yes · 0 No · 1 Unsure. Range 70–95/100. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudeYes85/100
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
Strong match to the brief: wardrobe, framing, setting and walking action are correct, with a good photographic look. Identity is a reasonably close match to the references; minor concerns are small face detail and a slightly lean build.
GeminiYes75/100
google/gemini-4-argon
The output preserves the reference face and body proportions within the requested daytime city sidewalk scene and wardrobe. Minor stiffness in the arm posture remains from the turnaround reference, but it is usable as is.
GrokYes80/100
x-ai/grok-4.7
The output is usable as-is: it preserves the referenced face and athletic proportions well enough while accurately delivering the requested full-body city walking shot and wardrobe. Minor leanness and smoothing do not create a major defect.
QwenYes95/100
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
Limited assessment: Still-image time offsets ignored. Face and body fully match approved references. Shot framing is nearly perfect, with only a minor margin tightness on feet. Visual quality and physical coherence are excellent. No artifacts or mismatches. Fully meets brief intent for a photorealistic walking shot.
MistralUnsure70/100
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0
Limited assessment: Still-image time offsets ignored. Generated image shows strong face likeness to reference (twists, goatee, studs, skin tone) and matching muscular body proportions. However, brief compliance has notable gaps: footwear appears to be black dress shoes rather than specified 'black low-top shoes' (casual), and while the walking pose and city sidewalk setting match, the eye-level camera with full head/feet margin is only partially met—

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial structure, hair, and beard match to reference 2 with negligible drift.
Body proportions · 3/4: Accurately reflects the requested athletic silhouette and proportions from reference 1.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Captures the full-body walking pose on a city sidewalk, 16:9 framing, and specified wardrobe.
Visual quality · 3/4: Photorealistic lighting and texture consistent with the requested daytime urban scene.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Plausible grounding, shadows, and perspective throughout the composition.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 2 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

AI 75/100Est. $0.1416/image

References

Reference details

Gravis · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Body direction accepted; left-profile panel remains three-quarter.

Gravis · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Current face reference; complete pack validation pending.

Attempt 2: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

gravis-action-structured. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.141552; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judges75/1005/5

3 Yes · 0 No · 2 Unsure. Range 70–100/100. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudeUnsure70/100
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
Limited assessment: Still-image time offsets ignored. face explanation shortened; full text retained. brief explanation shortened; full text retained. Strong shot and wardrobe match with a plausible body, but face likeness is only moderate: hair is less defined and ear studs are not visible. Face acceptance is pending per the brief, so using it as is remains uncertain.
GeminiYes75/100
google/gemini-4-argon
The output preserves the actor's face and body proportions from the references while meeting all wardrobe, pose, and framing requirements for the city sidewalk scene.
GrokYes100/100
x-ai/grok-4.7
The output preserves the referenced face and muscular proportions while delivering the requested natural sidewalk walk and wardrobe in a clean photographic frame. No major visual or coherence defects are visible.
QwenYes95/100
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
Limited assessment: Still-image time offsets ignored. Output meets all core requirements: face identity and body proportions match canonical references; shot framing, wardrobe, and environment align with brief. Minor background distraction doesn’t break continuity or recognition. Visual quality and physical coherence are photographic and artifact-free. Actor is clearly the same person across references. AS IS use is recommended.
MistralUnsure70/100
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0
Limited assessment: Still-image time offsets ignored. Generated image shows a recognizable match to the reference actor with correct hairstyle, facial hair, skin tone, and muscular build. The walking pose, wardrobe (navy shirt, charcoal trousers, black shoes), and city sidewalk setting align with brief intent. However, face acceptance remains pending per brief, and there are minor quality concerns: slight plastic skin texture, potential head scale en

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial resemblance to the reference, matching skin tone, hair, and facial hair accurately.
Body proportions · 3/4: Muscular build and proportions correspond well with the reference body silhouette.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately depicts the requested walking step, full-body framing, daytime street setting, and specified clothing.
Visual quality · 3/4: Realistic photographic quality with natural street lighting and clean integration.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Good anatomical coherence, plausible ground contact, and consistent perspective.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 3 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

AI 75/100Est. $0.1406/image

References

Reference details

Gravis · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Body direction accepted; left-profile panel remains three-quarter.

Gravis · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Current face reference; complete pack validation pending.

Attempt 3: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

gravis-cinematic-concise. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.140612; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judges75/1005/5

4 Yes · 1 No · 0 Unsure. Range 70–95/100. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudeYes75/100
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
Limited assessment: brief explanation shortened; full text retained. Strong cinematic rooftop frame with a close face match to the reference and mostly accurate brief adherence. Minor issues: the gaze is direct rather than past the camera, the jacket is glossy rather than matte, and the body is only partly verifiable.
GeminiNo70/100
google/gemini-4-argon
The output preserves the actor's facial identity and upper-body build well within a cinematic rainy rooftop scene. However, the subject looks directly into the lens instead of past the camera, and the jacket is glossy rather than matte as requested.
GrokYes80/100
x-ai/grok-4.7
Limited assessment: Still-image time offsets ignored. The output is usable as-is: it preserves the candidate face and visible muscular proportions in a convincing rainy rooftop frame. Minor gaze and wet-jacket deviations do not outweigh the strong overall match.
QwenYes95/100
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
Output meets or exceeds targets across all dimensions. Face and body match reference identity and proportions. Shot composition, lighting, and visual quality are cinematic and coherent. Minor gaze deviation does not break brief. No artifacts or incoherences. Suitable AS IS for the brief.
MistralYes75/100
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0
Limited assessment: Still-image time offsets ignored. Strong match to brief: rainy rooftop dusk setting, green-gray atmosphere, matte black jacket, waist-up eye-level framing, twists/taper with mustache/goatee and ear studs, calm determined expression looking past camera. Face and body broadly align with supplied references. Minor deviations: jacket material reads slightly synthetic, full body proportions unverifiable in waist-up crop, subtle facial-

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Facial features, hair twists, complexion, and facial hair accurately resemble the reference.
Body proportions · 3/4: Upper torso and shoulder proportions align well with the reference body silhouette.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Meets the requested dusk rooftop setting, rainy environment, jacket, framing, and expression.
Visual quality · 3/4: High photographic fidelity with convincing lighting, rain textures, and atmosphere.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Anatomy, perspective, wet surface reflections, and clothing render coherently.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 4 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

AI 75/100Est. $0.1408/image

References

Reference details

Gravis · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Body direction accepted; left-profile panel remains three-quarter.

Gravis · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Current face reference; complete pack validation pending.

Attempt 4: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

gravis-cinematic-structured. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.14079; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judges75/1005/5

4 Yes · 0 No · 1 Unsure. Range 65–100/100. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudeUnsure65/100
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
Strong cinematic rooftop still with a broadly similar face and the right wardrobe and setting. Identity match and muscular build are not fully certain, and gaze direction and crop deviate from the brief.
GeminiYes75/100
google/gemini-4-argon
The generated still matches the brief and provided references well, maintaining facial identity, upper-body proportions, wardrobe, and rainy rooftop atmosphere without major defects.
GrokYes75/100
x-ai/grok-4.7
Usable as-is production still: the actor reads as the same person, proportions in frame match the references, and the rainy rooftop brief is met with only minor wardrobe sheen and crop limits.
QwenYes100/100
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
Limited assessment: Still-image time offsets ignored. All dimensions meet the brief: face and body match reference anatomy and expression; framing, lighting, and setting are accurate; visual quality is cinematic and coherent. No major defects or artifacts observed. Output is usable as a live-action production still.
MistralYes75/100
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0
Limited assessment: Still-image time offsets ignored. Generated output is a strong match to the brief. The actor's face preserves identity from the reference (skin tone, twists, facial hair, ear studs) with a calm determined expression. Body shows muscular build with appropriate proportions. The rainy rooftop dusk setting, matte black jacket, waist-up eye-level framing, and green-gray cinematic atmosphere all align with specifications. Minor dedu

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial likeness and hair structure matching Reference 2 with consistent facial hair and ear studs.
Body proportions · 3/4: Visible torso and shoulder proportions generally align with the muscular reference build.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately depicts the rainy rooftop environment, dusk lighting, matte black jacket, framing, and aspect ratio.
Visual quality · 3/4: High photographic fidelity with convincing wet surfaces, rain streaks, and cinematic atmospheric lighting.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Lighting and perspective are physically plausible with minor rain drop rendering artifacts against the jacket.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 5 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

2/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.141/image

References

Reference details

Gravis · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Body direction accepted; left-profile panel remains three-quarter.

Gravis · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Current face reference; complete pack validation pending.

Attempt 5: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

gravis-product-concise. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.141012; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending2/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudeUnsure70/100
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
Limited assessment: Still-image time offsets ignored. brief explanation shortened; full text retained. Good brief match and a strong face match with a clean photoreal look. The body does not clearly show the muscular build from the reference, and the face likeness is imperfect, so use as-is is uncertain.
GeminiNo70/100
google/gemini-4-argon
The output preserves the reference face and upper-body proportions well within a realistic scene, but it reverses the requested handedness by holding the bottle in the actor's left hand instead of the right hand.
GrokReview unavailable—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial structure, hair, and earring match to reference, with only minor variance in facial hair detailing.
Body proportions · 3/4: Shoulder width and seated torso proportions remain consistent with the reference frame.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately represents the requested medium shot, unbranded bottle, desk setting, and navy shirt.
Visual quality · 3/4: Photographic quality with balanced soft window lighting and realistic surface textures.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Natural hand interaction with the bottle and plausible seated anatomy without noticeable structural defects.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 6 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1412/image

References

Reference details

Gravis · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Body direction accepted; left-profile panel remains three-quarter.

Gravis · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Current face reference; complete pack validation pending.

Attempt 6: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

gravis-product-structured. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.141226; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Facial likeness, hair, facial hair, and earrings closely match the reference.
Body proportions · 3/4: Shoulder width, arm musculature, and overall build align with the reference silhouette.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Correct medium shot, desk setting, plain navy shirt, and skincare bottle held upright in right hand.
Visual quality · 3/4: High-quality photographic texture with natural lighting and sharp focus.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Hand anatomy, object interaction, and surface contact are natural and physically coherent.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 7 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1407/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 7: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-action-concise. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.140704; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial likeness and hair styling consistent with the canonical reference sheets.
Body proportions · 3/4: Curvy silhouette and overall proportions well-aligned with the reference model.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately depicts full-body framing, walking pose on a city sidewalk, and requested attire.
Visual quality · 3/4: Clean photographic realism, natural daylighting, and sharp focus throughout.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Ground contact, perspective, and lighting are physically consistent with no notable artifacts.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 8 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1415/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 8: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-action-structured. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.141538; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong likeness with minor differences in hairstyle softness and volume compared to the canonical reference.
Body proportions · 3/4: Curvy silhouette and overall proportions match the reference with minor deviations.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Full-body walking shot on a sidewalk, matching wardrobe specifications closely.
Visual quality · 3/4: High photographic realism, coherent natural lighting, and sharp textures.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Consistent anatomy, realistic foot contact, and believable shadows.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 9 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1419/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 9: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-cinematic-concise. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.141874; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial likeness to the reference identity, including the curl style and features, with minor softening.
Body proportions · 3/4: The visible upper-body proportions and silhouette appropriately match the reference frame.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately represents the rainy rooftop, dusk setting, 16:9 framing, and matte black jacket requested in the prompt.
Visual quality · 3/4: Cinematic visual quality, believable rain reflections, and coherent lighting across the scene.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Consistent anatomy, correct perspective, and physically plausible ambient reflections.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 10 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1408/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 10: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-cinematic-structured. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.1408; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong likeness to the face reference, showing consistent facial structure and blonde wavy hair, with minor variation in jawline sharpness.
Body proportions · 3/4: Torso silhouette and general proportions closely mirror the reference, with reasonable shoulder-to-hip alignment under the jacket.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Follows requested framing, rainy rooftop setting, matte black jacket, and calm expression accurately.
Visual quality · 3/4: Cinematic lighting, high-level photographic clarity, and believable environmental integration without notable rendering artifacts.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Physical elements, lighting integration, and clothing drapery are anatomically and spatially sound.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 11 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1404/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 11: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-product-concise. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.140354; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial structure, hair color, and styling match the canonical reference with minor variances.
Body proportions · 3/4: Upper body proportions and silhouette reasonably reflect the reference frame.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately represents pose, unbranded skincare bottle, navy shirt, desk setting, and lighting.
Visual quality · 3/4: Clear photographic rendering, soft window lighting, and clean background separation.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Natural hand-object contact and seated desk posture without severe anatomical artifacts.

Lower body is occluded by desk, limiting full silhouette verification.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 12 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1412/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 12: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-product-structured. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.141176; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial likeness to reference 2 with consistent blonde waves and facial features.
Body proportions · 3/4: Upper body proportions and silhouette reasonably align with reference 1, seated framing conceals lower body.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately represents pose, unbranded white cylinder bottle, navy shirt, soft lighting, and desk framing.
Visual quality · 3/4: Natural photographic texture, sharp focus, clean lighting, no severe artifacts.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Consistent physical contact with desk and held object, natural anatomy.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 13 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1406/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 13: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-product-concise-sheets-v1. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.140624; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Facial features, eye shape, and blonde curls align closely with reference 2.
Body proportions · 3/4: Upper body proportions and torso build match the reference silhouette well.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Holds the unbranded white cylindrical bottle in right hand, navy shirt, seated at desk, window light.
Visual quality · 3/4: High photorealistic fidelity with clean textures and natural indoor lighting.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Hands, desk contact, reflections, and object hold appear structurally plausible.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 14 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1403/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 14: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-product-concise-sheets-v1-owner-retry-01. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.140276; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial resemblance and hair match to reference.
Body proportions · 3/4: Upper body proportions and silhouette reasonably align with reference.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Follows the requested pose, framing, wardrobe, and prop placement.
Visual quality · 3/4: Photorealistic rendering and soft window lighting without obvious artifacts.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Physical geometry, desk contact, and hand holding bottle are coherent.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 15 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1404/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 15: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-action-concise-sheets-v1. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.14041; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Facial likeness matches the reference character well, including hair style and features.
Body proportions · 3/4: Body silhouette and proportions align reasonably well with the approved reference.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately represents walking step, outfit, setting, aspect ratio, and full-body composition.
Visual quality · 3/4: High visual quality with natural lighting and realistic textures throughout.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Geometry, contacts, shadows, and perspective are physically sound and coherent.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 16 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.141/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 16: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-action-structured-sheets-v1. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.14098; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Facial features and blonde curls align closely with reference 2.
Body proportions · 3/4: Curvy silhouette and overall proportions remain consistent with reference 1.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Walking pose, navy shirt, charcoal trousers, sidewalk setting, and 16:9 framing match the prompt.
Visual quality · 3/4: Natural daytime lighting and cohesive photorealistic rendering throughout the frame.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Grounding and anatomy are physically consistent with no glaring artifacts.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 17 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1414/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 17: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-cinematic-concise-sheets-v1. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.141388; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Facial structure, blonde curls, and features closely align with the reference sheet with minor subtle variations.
Body proportions · 3/4: Upper body silhouette and proportions remain generally consistent with reference 1 within the medium framing.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Successfully captures the medium shot, rainy rooftop setting, fitted jacket, and calm expression.
Visual quality · 3/4: Realistic photographic quality with natural lighting and rain textures, lacking obvious rendering artifacts.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Consistent scene geometry, believable wet reflections, and proper anatomical form throughout the frame.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 18 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1421/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 18: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-cinematic-structured-sheets-v1. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.142114; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Facial structure, blonde curls, and features closely match the identity reference with minor variations in hair styling.
Body proportions · 3/4: Proportions align well with the reference body silhouette and requested build.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately represents the rainy rooftop setting, fitted jacket, framing, and mood specified in the brief.
Visual quality · 3/4: High visual quality with natural lighting, sharp textures, and atmospheric coherence.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Consistent physical interaction with rain effects, lighting reflections, and correct anatomy.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 19 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1411/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 19: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-product-structured-sheets-v1. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.141062; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial likeness and hair styling matching reference 2.
Body proportions · 3/4: Upper body build, bust, and proportions align well with reference 1.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: All prompt elements present: seated, desk, navy shirt, white bottle held at chest height.
Visual quality · 3/4: Realistic photo aesthetic with clean soft window lighting and natural textures.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Anatomy, hand grip, and desk contact appear physically consistent.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 20 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1424/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 20: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-action-concise-silhouette-v2-flex. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs. Same model on Standard instead of the historical Flex tier.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.1424; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong likeness to reference face and hair with minor facial smoothing.
Body proportions · 3/4: Accurately reflects the reference build and silhouette with minor waist tucking.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Adheres well to setting, wardrobe, framing, and action specifications.
Visual quality · 3/4: Photorealistic render with natural lighting and depth of field.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Plausible anatomy, ground contact, and perspective throughout.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 21 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1409/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 21: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-action-structured-silhouette-v2-flex. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs. Same model on Standard instead of the historical Flex tier.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.140932; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Facial features, eye color, and blonde curled bob closely match the identity reference with minor variations.
Body proportions · 3/4: Body silhouette and proportions align well with the reference model's build, including hip and bust fullness.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Successfully captures the walking action, full-body framing, daytime city setting, and described wardrobe elements.
Visual quality · 3/4: Photorealistic visual quality, natural daytime lighting, consistent focus, and realistic material textures.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Plausible grounding, consistent shadows, and anatomically natural stride and arm swing.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 22 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1409/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 22: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-cinematic-concise-silhouette-v2-flex. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs. Same model on Standard instead of the historical Flex tier.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.1409; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Strong facial likeness and matching hairstyle, though slightly matured compared to Reference 2.
Body proportions · 3/4: Proportions and silhouette largely reflect the fuller build from Reference 1 with minor slimming at the waist.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately depicts medium shot framing, rainy rooftop setting, atmosphere, and requested wardrobe.
Visual quality · 3/4: High photographic fidelity, convincing lighting, and wet surface textures with no significant artifacts.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Consistent environmental geometry, believable reflections, and coherent anatomy.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 23 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1421/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 23: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-cinematic-structured-silhouette-v2-flex. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs. Same model on Standard instead of the historical Flex tier.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.142144; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 70/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 70/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Facial structure, eyes, and curly blonde hair closely align with reference 2, with minor styling differences.
Body proportions · 2/4: The proportions appear slimmer and more tapered than the specified fuller body reference in image 1.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Environment, rainy rooftop setting, matte black jacket, and framing match the prompt requirements well.
Visual quality · 3/4: Photographic quality, motivated wet lighting, and background depth are effectively rendered.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Anatomy and environmental reflections remain physically consistent throughout the frame.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 24 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.141/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 24: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-product-concise-silhouette-v2-flex. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs. Same model on Standard instead of the historical Flex tier.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.140954; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Good resemblance to the face reference, maintaining the hair style, color, and key facial traits.
Body proportions · 3/4: Upper body proportions and build reasonably match the reference sheet within the medium crop.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Accurately represents the requested medium shot, seated posture, desk, shirt, and skincare bottle.
Visual quality · 3/4: Clean photorealistic render with balanced indoor window lighting and minimal visible artifacts.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Natural hand interaction, stable anatomy, and consistent lighting and shadows overall.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Attempt 25 · Google Nano Banana Pro ↗

Raw image

0/5 AI reviewsEst. $0.1415/image

References

Reference details

Iris · body sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved body direction, 5′2″ / 130 lb.

Iris · face sheet: Exact sheet submitted to this attempt. Owner-approved face and expression sheet.

Attempt 25: generated result — Generated result

Changes & cost

iris-product-structured-silhouette-v2-flex. New body and face sheet inputs; stature/build phrases updated. Historical shot direction retained; one raw attempt, no retries or repairs. Same model on Standard instead of the historical Flex tier.

Human acceptance and likeness are pending. Body measurements are design targets, not pixel-verified anatomy.

Nano Banana Pro · gemini-3-pro-image · direct Google · Standard

Usage estimate $0.141526; invoice, fees and taxes unknown. Native 2752 × 1536.

Look for: Face likeness · Body shape · Scene fit

AI judgesFive-judge review pending0/5

A panel score needs five compatible numeric scores. Unknown results are not zero. AI diagnostics; community votes and Miguel’s verdict stay separate.

ClaudePending—
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
GeminiPending—
google/gemini-4-argon
GrokPending—
x-ai/grok-4.7
QwenPending—
qwen/qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct
MistralPending—
mistralai/mistral-large-4-0

Video frame reviews cover sampled visuals; they do not certify audio, lip sync or every frame.

Earlier reviews · 1

Gemini 3.8 Flash · 75/100
Earlier visual rubric · 2026-10-13. Earlier model/rubric; excluded from this five-judge score.

Earlier AI review: 75/100
Community: Vote below ↓
Miguel’s verdict: Pending

Earlier judge details

Gemini 3.8 Flash. One visual judge, not yet calibrated against Miguel. Rubric points, not a likeness percentage.

Face likeness · 3/4: Facial features, eye color, and curled blonde hair closely match the reference identity with minor rendering smoothing.
Body proportions · 3/4: Torso proportions and bust volume reflect the reference well, though the seated crop limits lower body verification.
Shot accuracy · 3/4: Framing, pose, props, wardrobe, and desk setting align accurately with all key requirements of the brief.
Visual quality · 3/4: Photorealistic image quality with natural lighting and consistent texture throughout the frame.
Physical coherence · 3/4: Anatomy, object contact with the bottle, and desk perspective are physically plausible and coherent.

Lower body silhouette is occluded by the desk, preventing assessment of hips and legs.

Judged against the released historical references, not a newer character pack.

Gemini 3.8 Flash · visual rubric v1 · 2026-10-13. Human votes stay separate.

Voting help

If your browser blocks embedded sign-in, open this review separately ↗. Votes and Credits use the same Navo account.

Results

Compare each face and build with its references. This is a scene history, not a model comparison; acceptance and final billing are unconfirmed.

Method, costs & limits

Exploratory tests with unchanged outputs and recorded failures. Model names are visible before voting; votes do not establish a model-wide winner.

Judge face, head scale and body shape together. Historical shot directions are retained. Six former Flex attempts use Standard on the same Google model, explicitly labeled. These changing prompt arms are not a controlled model ranking.

Human acceptance, usable rate and invoice costs are unknown. Gravis’s body sheet has a three-quarter panel rather than a true left profile, and his face pack is not fully validated. Fifteen historical attempts remain unsubmitted: six need the exact original movie frame; nine need route checks, including five dependent scene inputs. Earlier votes are not pooled with this cohort.

Can AI keep our cast consistent?

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

References

Results

AGV Report